Practices struggle with patient message overload

As patient portal messages increase, medical practices are looking for ways to handle them effectively. A panel of experts suggests that integrating electronic responses into staffing, schedules, and technology can help. Libby Hoy, founder and CEO of Patient and Family Centered Care Partners, notes that patients don’t ask for asynchronous care—they want to know whether their messages are being received and who is handling them.
Hoy spoke during a panel on asynchronous primary care access at a public meeting of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine Standing Committee on Primary Care. The panel was moderated by Ishani Ganguli, M.D., M.P.H., associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School and a primary care physician at Brigham and Women’s Hospital.
Patient-authored portal messages have risen about 150% from 2020 to 2025, according to Ganguli, citing a study of Epic Cosmos data. One health system estimates that its primary care physicians spend about 2½ hours in the inbox per clinic day.
Who Answers the Messages?
At HealthLinc, a federally qualified health center, each team is centered around a physician and two nurse practitioners, with medical assistants and other support staff. Lawrence D. Ramunno, M.D., M.P.H., MBA, chief medical officer of HealthLinc, says that patients who need transportation help should hear from the community health worker, while those who need medication adjustments should hear from the pharmacist.
Ramunno notes that HealthLinc’s pharmacists share a common inbox for medication refills and prior authorizations, allowing work to be distributed among them. He emphasizes the importance of transparency, telling patients that a reply from a team member is still a reply from the team.
Ramunno also highlights the challenge of knowing when a message thread should become a visit, particularly in a health center where patients may have complex conditions or transportation problems. He notes that it’s not possible for one person to handle all messages, even with the help of AI agents.
At Firefly Health, a virtual-first primary care practice, nurses, nonclinical staff, and AI assistants handle incoming chats first, routing refills, billing questions, and clinical concerns to the right person. Jeff Greenberg, M.D., MBA, co-founder of Firefly Health, says that nurse practitioners and physicians have about 25% of their time set aside for asynchronous care.
Related Post: Medical Practices Face Staffing Challenges
Greenberg notes that messaging can also make proactive care easier, allowing providers to reach out to patients with test results or other important information. He says that patients are often amazed when they receive proactive outreach from their provider.
Alan Evans, M.D., a family physician and regional assistant medical director for the Virtual Medical Center at Southern California Permanente Medical Group, says that Kaiser Permanente uses AI to read each message, categorize it, and route it to the right group. He notes that message management continues through weekends.
Hoy cautions that human clinicians must still build trust with patients, and that AI should be used transparently. She shares a patient’s experience who praised a helpful nurse named Megan at her cardiology clinic, only to learn later that Megan was AI.
Hoy emphasizes the importance of setting expectations with patients about response time and urgency, and showing them where their messages are in the process. She notes that patients should be able to track their messages, just like they can track a pizza delivery.
Hoy quotes one patient partner as saying, “I don’t know where my messages go.” She urges practices to involve patients and family caregivers in designing new message systems, and to be transparent about how patient input is used.
Practices should inform patients about the status of their messages, including when a response is pending or when a message needs to become a visit.
